Slowbro w/ C/P vs Poliwrath w/ Bubble/ Sub or IP
Which of those would you fear most as an attacker and why?
Answers
Poliwrath with Bubble / Ice Punch is IMO one of the most frightening defenders, given the limitations of defense vs. attack in this game.
Slowbro with Confusion / Ice Beam (which I like much more than Psychic simply for how hard it can hit Dragonite) is nearly as powerful, though.
Both are strong defenders but with pitifully low CP after the changes. Gyms would be much more fun as a mechanic if players could not put more than one of the same mon in each.
You will certainly annoy members of your own team, if you stick them in an early stage gym with 5 or less Pokémon in, and it's going to sit on the bottom, you can pretty much guarantee that gym isn't going much higher. You can use them if you want as the 8th or more Pokémon in a gym and while they are tough, you will be little annoyed by all the bad mons you are helping protect that people have put in just to jockey for CP position.
If you made me pick one it would Slowbro, but I never use mine. I've got both and they just collect dust, sad because they were a couple of my favorites before the CP changes.
What I'm really wanting is a Slowbro with Water Pulse and Psychic to use as a prestiger against Snorlax.