How to get a shiny karp
I have not tested it for myself, but there seems to be a reliable strategy to get a shiny karp in short time:
https://articles.pokebattler.com/2017/05/18/potential-new-research-i-just-caught-four-shiny-magikarp-using-chaining/
Has anybody here tried this already?
Answers
Interesting read, I never even knew about the 10th pokestop reward thing.
I theorised shiny karp to be something like the initial ditto theory in which cluster spawns of rattatas/pidgeys means that one of them will be ditto. (Today ditto are totally random I think)
For my shinykarp I caught it in a spawn of 2 next to each other (both were normal coloured initially), but that is with a sample of 1, so you know how reliable that is.
I've caught 5 shiny magikarp
The first three catches were not in a chain, but they were the first weekend of release of the Shiny.
the last two could have been in chains, because when I bicycle the bay trail into work, I tend to only select and catch the magikarp. I can usually catch them on the first throw, thus they don't Mon-Block a possible dratini. (I really don't want to miss a spawned dratini showing up on my screen because I'm spending too much time trying to catch another mon)
After this rock event is done, I try chaining magikarp, and report back to this group.
(I'll only break the chain if a dratini appears!)
As if I needed another excuse to visit my favorite magikarp park in the city! I should be able to test this, there are usually enough karp.
During the event; I caught 3 shinies in 2 days, but I caught everything and didn't focus on karp (and didn't catch a lot of them). But nothing since the event, and I've caught lots if karp... that dark orange color is now always a disappointment ;)
Will report any interesting findings.